Court throws out $135m claim over mobile licence
AI summary
Malawi has escaped paying K235 billion to a South African businessman over a mobile phone licence that never took off.
The African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights on Friday dismissed a $135.3 million claim by Patroklos Tsaperas, ruling that he filed his case too late.
Tsaperas, a shareholder in Malawi Mobile Limited (MML), wanted $133.7 million in compensation for lost revenue, $400 000 refund of licence fees and $1.2 million in legal costs.
Mbeta: It’s a huge relief.
I Nation
His claim stemmed from a 2002 deal in which MML was licensed by the Malawi Communications Regulatory Authority (Macra) to provide mobile services for 15 years.
Under the agreement signed on April 19 2002, MML was to pay $100 000 a year in licence fees and roll out services within 12 months. It paid $400 000 in total.
Macra revoked the licence on February 9 2005, demanding outstanding fees and penalties. Tsaperas alleged a later agreement extended the deadline to October 31, 2005, but government interference led to revocation anyway.
MML sued in the High Court in May 2005. In April 2012, the High Court awarded the company $66.85 million. The Supreme Court of Appeal overturned that award on March 10, 2015.MML then went to the Comesa Court of Justice, which in April 2017 ruled it had no jurisdiction. A review application was dismissed in September 2021.
Tsaperas then approached the African Court in 2022.Delivering the judgment, Judge Imani Daud Aboud said the court had jurisdiction, but the application was inadmissible because it was not filed within a reasonable time. Each party will bear its own costs.
The government, defended by former Attorney General Thabo Chakaka Nyirenda and Senior State Advocate Nerverson Chisiza, argued there was no valid contract, Macra did not breach it, and MML failed to prove any loss.
Attorney General Frank Mbeta, who attended the session, described the ruling as a huge relief.”It’s a huge relief to Macra and the Government,” Mbeta said.
Tsaperas’ lawyer, David Kanyenda, said copies of the majority and dissenting opinions were not yet available.
“The absence of complete unanimity reveals that our client’s position and arguments resonated with some members of the panel,” Kanyenda said on Friday evening.
The post Court throws out $135m claim over mobile licence appeared first on Nation Online.
Follow the story
About this article
- Length
- 383 words · 2 min read
- Published
- November 15, 2026
- Byline
- Joseph Mwale
- Source
- The Nation Malawi