Man Utd offer Pochettino opportunity over ‘unfinished business’ – opinion
Mauricio Pochettino has the defining chance to prove himself in one all-important way once his Old Trafford reign as Manchester United manager begins this week. ...

AI summary
Mauricio Pochettino has the defining chance to prove himself in one all-important way once his Old Trafford reign as Manchester United manager begins this week.
The 54-year-old Argentine manager has only one match remaining in his USA managerial tenure before he bows out of the States and heads to Manchester.
Mauricio Pochettino agreed to become Manchester United’s next manager last week after Ineos made the call to sack Michael Carrick during the November break.
Jamie Carragher has now highlighted a valid observation of how United could offer the outgoing United States boss Pochettino the opportunity to ‘evolve’ as a manager.
READ MORE: Rio Ferdinand can’t see Man Utd landing Fernandes replacement
Man Utd could transform Mauricio Pochettino into an ‘elite’ manager based on his achievements rather than his reputation
Speaking on The Overlap Fan Debate, Jamie Carragher highlighted that Mauricio Pochettino has a “reputation” as one of the “big managers” in football. However, the 48-year-old Sky Sports pundit feels that his reputation does not necessarily make him an ‘elite’ coach in the same bracket as Jurgen Klopp or Pep Guardiola.
“And I think it’s an interesting thing with Poch as well,” Carragher said.
“And I’ve said this before, it’s not a criticism, it’s probably a fact, really, in that he’s got a reputation as one of the ‘big managers.’ And when he was at Tottenham, he was going up against Klopp, Pep in the league, whoever was the Manchester United manager at the time, and really handled himself really well, getting great results.
“But he’s managed to keep that reputation without actually winning the biggest trophies yet. So, Manchester United, one of the biggest clubs in the world, gives him that opportunity over the next few years to do that. But it will be interesting to see.”
Pochettino was able to maintain that reputation after he was sacked by Tottenham in 2019. The former Spurs boss was able to bounce his way back to brief spells at Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea before he became the United States head coach in 2024. However, reputation can only take a manager so far, as Pochettino has never felt that he was truly in the ‘world-class’ tier like Jurgen Klopp or Pep Guardiola.
Instead, Manchester United now presents the chance for Pochettino to become an elite manager. Gapping up from a respected coach to an elite one should be a top priority for Pochettino after he landed one of the biggest — and most challenging — roles in world football. Pochettino’s situation should be treated differently from Klopp, who arrived at Anfield in 2015 on the back of his success with Borussia Dortmund.
How long since Mauricio Pochettino’s last major silverware win — the Ligue 1 trophy with PSG in April 2022 — as a football manager:
-
Total number of days
: 1,669 days
-
Total time
: four years, six months and 25 days
Pochettino’s only form of major silverware success came during his single season at PSG after he captured the Ligue 1 title and the French Cup. But the domestic trophies were not enough to save the former Chelsea and Tottenham boss from receiving the sack. PSG desired the Champions League trophy and winning Europe’s top club prize at that time would have been a sign of Pochettino’s elite status as a manager.
There is now a compelling narrative for Pochettino at United, ranging from putting a project in place that could lead the Red Devils back to the Champions League to being the manager to capture their first Premier League title since 2013. Pochettino has the reputation and Premier League experience that are invaluable for Man Utd in the post-Michael Carrick era.
READ MORE: Pochettino claims Man Utd narrowly avoided ‘impossible’ scenario
Despite being able to hold his own in the Premier League era of the Klopp vs Guardiola rivalry, Pochettino is lacking the trophy-winning achievements that put him in the same bracket as the former Manchester City manager and ex-Liverpool boss. United cannot instantly transform Pochettino into an elite manager overnight. Just like Pochettino’s reputation at Tottenham, the Red Devils’ symbolic history holds them up in world football amid the turbulence of the post-Sir Alex Ferguson era.
“And also, a lot of his success, as a manager, is probably you’re talking — we keep going back to Tottenham, that was, what, seven, eight years ago, 10 years ago?” Carragher asked.
“Okay. So, we’re talking a few years now. So, there is that question mark and I think that’s fair to ask that. So, who thinks he’ll be a success? What is a success?”
Pochettino has had some of the biggest roles in football. However, United seems like his perfect shot at building a defining reputation as an elite football coach if he can do what his seven predecessors post-Sir Alex Ferguson failed to do. Man Utd could be the platform where Pochettino’s presence in Klopp and Guardiola’s company becomes a more reasonable comparison if he can build a special project at Old Trafford.
Pochettino has spent years being talked about in the football discourse as one of the elite managers in the world. However, Man Utd could finally be the club where the opportunity to become one is merited by what he actually achieves, including winning the Premier League title or the Champions League trophy.
Follow the story
About this article
- Length
- 889 words · 4 min read
- Published
- November 17, 2026
- Byline
- Adnan Riaz
- Source
- United In Focus