ConCourt reserves judgment in challenges to Mnangagwa term extension
AI summary
The Constitutional Court on Wednesday, 18 November, reserved judgment in two challenges to constitutional amendments extending President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s rule to 2030.
The challenges concern amendments signed into law by Mnangagwa in July, extending his current presidential term by two years, from 2028 to 2030, while also extending the tenure of MPs who supported the legislation.
The changes have triggered a major legal and political dispute over presidential succession, electoral timelines and whether amendments extending the tenure of incumbents can lawfully benefit those already holding office.
Both applicants are seeking direct access to the Constitutional Court to have their challenges determined by the country’s highest court.
The first challenge was brought by Vhurande Mahlupeko, who is contesting the constitutionality of the amendments and the process through which they were introduced.
The second was brought by former opposition legislator Prince Dubeko Sibanda, who is contesting the application of the amendments to Mnangagwa and sitting MPs who voted for the legislation.
Lawyers argued that the entire legislation should be struck down over alleged procedural violations in Parliament and that the extensions should not benefit the incumbent president and MPs.
Mahlupeko argues that about 10 provisions, including those expanding the Constitutional Court, were inserted into the Bill without first being published in the Government Gazette for public consultation. He is seeking an order declaring the contested amendments invalid over the alleged procedural irregularities.
Constitutional lawyer Lovemore Madhuku, representing the applicants, said the court had heard arguments challenging the insertion of the 10 provisions, which were not included in the original gazetted proposals.
Speaking to journalists outside court, Madhuku said the applicants wanted the entire Constitutional Amendment Act No. 3 invalidated if the court found that the provisions had been introduced without following the constitutionally prescribed procedure.
“Our arguments were intended to show that they had not complied with the requirements in Section 328(3), which would not allow Parliament to proceed to deal with any constitutional provision that was not part of the case stated in the notice.”
Section 328(3) requires Parliament to give public notice of exactly which provisions it intends to change. The applicants say Parliament cannot later deal with provisions that were not listed in that notice because the public was never consulted on them.
Madhuku said selectively removing the disputed provisions through what lawyers call the “blue-pencil test” would fundamentally change the legislation approved by Parliament, potentially undermining the basis on which lawmakers voted for it.
“We argued that if they were to do so, the Bill would be different from what it was when Parliament passed it. We don’t know why people voted for this particular Bill. They might have voted for it because of those provisions that would have been removed by the judges,” he said.
According to Madhuku, the government argued that the additional provisions were permissible because a memorandum accompanying the Bill had provided scope to consider governance issues and other matters beyond the original proposals.
He said judges had asked extensive questions about the procedure followed in introducing the provisions, although he declined to speculate on the eventual ruling.
The applicants also argued that Mnangagwa had a conflict of interest when he signed the Bill into law because its provisions conferred benefits on him, and should therefore have recused himself.
Sibanda is seeking to prevent the amendments from benefiting the current president and parliamentarians, arguing that Section 328(7) of the Constitution prohibits constitutional changes extending presidential and parliamentary terms from benefiting officeholders who were already in power when the amendments were enacted.
Madhuku said the Government had largely focused its opposition on whether the Constitutional Court had jurisdiction to hear Sibanda’s application directly, arguing that the alleged obligation at issue was not a constitutional matter that could be brought straight before the apex court.
He said the applicants had countered that Parliament was not disputing the requirements of Section 328 but instead arguing that the word “notwithstanding” in the legislation had overridden those requirements.
“Parliament in court was not denying that Section 328 said that. They were saying they had overridden it. They were saying it was overridden by the expression ‘notwithstanding’,” Madhuku said.
“Our argument was that ‘notwithstanding’ cannot be a basis for you to shy away from the obligation, whether you vote for it or not.”
He said he was confident that the applicants had presented a strong case and were now awaiting the court’s decision.
More: NewZimbabwe.com
Follow the story
About this article
- Length
- 735 words · 4 min read
- Published
- November 19, 2026
- Byline
- Lovemore
- Source
- Pindula News