Opinion | It is cadre first
"It wrote: “We Belong, We Care, We Serve”, and then taught its members to belong to a faction, to care about tenders, and to serve themselves."
AI summary
In 1997, the ANC, still fresh in government and still fluent in the language of liberation, authored one of the finest public service charters on the continent: Batho Pele — People First. It was an eightpoint promise that the new state would not behave like the old one. It promised consultation, service standards, access, courtesy, information, openness and transparency, redress and value for money.
It was a moral document before it was a bureaucratic one. It said to the black majority who had been treated as non-citizens by apartheid: You are now the centre of the state. The bureaucrat works for you, not the other way around. Almost 30 years later, the authors have become the chief violators of their own text. The failure is not one of policy, but of practice.
The ANC does not need to be taught Batho Pele. It needs to be reminded that it wrote it. Batho Pele demands that citizens must be consulted about the level and quality of services they receive.
What consultation happens in Mangaung, in uMshwathi, in Ngquza Hill, some of the very municipalities where the ANC almost failed, until rescued by a recent Constitutional Court judgment, to register candidates because someone forgot to press the “submit” button? Consultation has been replaced by tenderpreneurial imposition.
ALSO READ | Mandeni councillor removed from office over serious misconduct
Communities are told after the fact that their water will be cut for 12 hours, that their clinic has no medicine, that a R400million water contract has been awarded to a company with no trucks. Public meetings are called to endorse decisions already taken at Luthuli House.
The people are not consulted; they are managed. Batho Pele says citizens must be told what level and quality of service to expect, and that all citizens should have equal access. Walk into any Home Affairs office in Johannesburg at 5am and you will see South Africans sleeping on the pavement to get an ID.
Walk into a public clinic in KwaMashu at 6am and you will see grandmothers queuing for files that will never be found. That is not a standard. That is humiliation. Access has become a function of who you know. If you know a councillor, your pothole is fixed. If you know a comrade, your CV moves to the top.
If you don’t, you join the over 30% unemployed who are told to “be patient” while water tankers, owned by politically-connected individuals, are dispatched to sell back to the state what the state failed to deliver. The white paper said officials must treat citizens with courtesy and consideration. It said information must be made available in full. It said administration must be open.
ALSO READ | SARS tax deadline: What happens if you miss Friday’s cut-off?
When last did a mayor answer a phone call from a resident? When last did a municipality publish a full supply chain report without being forced by a court? The default posture of the ANC-run state has become defensive, opaque and rude.
Communities file the freedom of information law (PAIA) requests to find out how their own money was spent and receive redacted documents two years later. Whistle-blowers who embody Batho Pele’s principle of openness, like Babita Deokaran, are murdered. Those who ask about information are labelled counter-revolutionary. Not forgetting the profanities meted out to the public by government officials.
Courtesy has been inverted. The citizen must be courteous to the official, lest the file is moved to the bottom of the pile. These are the two principles that indict the ANC most severely. Redress says when services fail, there must be a swift, sympathetic remedy and an apology. SA has instead perfected the art of no apology. Eskom’s loadshedding destroyed small businesses for years with no redress.
The pit toilets that killed Michael Komape in 2014 and Lumka Mketwa in 2018 produced commissions of inquiry, not accountability. Municipalities that lose billions in irregular expenditure, Mangaung again, with billions of rand in unauthorised spending in one audit, simply table the report and continue. Value for money? Batho Pele says public services must be provided economically and efficiently.
ALSO READ | Thebolla hails teamwork as Msunduzi administration term draws to a close
The auditor-general has told us every year what value for money looks like under the ANC: Millions spent on a military hospital that doesn’t work, millions spent on a school with no pupils. Batho Pele demands that public money be treated as sacred because it is the people’s money. The ANC’s deployment committee treats it as party money.
What went wrong is not complicated. Batho Pele was written for a developmental state. The ANC built a deployment state. A developmental state asks: “Does this person have the skill to serve the people?” A deployment state asks: “Does this person have loyalty to the faction?” You cannot have “People First” when “Cadre First” is the operating system.
The eight principles require merit, discipline and shame. Cadre deployment requires loyalty, protection and impunity. The two cannot coexist. In 1997, the ANC authored Batho Pele to convince South Africans that it would not become what it fought against.
In 2026, the queues at SA Social Security Agency offices, the dry taps in Hammanskraal, the unanswered emails to ward councillors, prove that it has. The tragedy is not that the ANC failed to implement a policy. Governments fail all the time. The tragedy is that it failed to live up to its own conscience. It wrote: “We Belong, We Care, We Serve”, and then taught its members to belong to a faction, to care about tenders, and to serve themselves. Batho Pele does not need to be rewritten. It needs to be re-read, by its authors.
Nhlanhla Mbatha is a current affairs analyst.
Follow the story
About this article
- Length
- 962 words · 5 min read
- Published
- October 22, 2026
- Byline
- Nhlanhla Mbatha
- Source
- The Witness